George Szell / The Cleveland Orchestra – Beethoven: Symphony No. 1 (Franklin Mint pressing, red vinyl) – NEW RIP!

# Composer: Ludwig van Beethoven
# Orchestra: The Cleveland Orchestra
# Conductor: George Szell
# Vinyl (1964? / 1981)
# Number of Discs: 1
# Format: FLAC
# DR Analysis: DR 13
# Label: Franklin Mint Record Society | Record 87 of 100
# Size: 24-bit/192kHz (1.03GB), 24-bit/96kHz (541MB) and 16-bit/44.1kHz (154MB)
# Recovery: 5%
# Scan: yes
# Servers: File Factory

Shortly before the holidays last year, I got a PM letting me know that there was a skip in the second movement of this rip. The original was done almost two years ago and grabbed over 250 times. No one had said a word till now.

Normally, I would just copy/paste a fix and repost that track. Unfortunately (for me), that wasn’t possible, because I had changed my cart and preamp since then. A copy/paste job would most likely be noticeable. So what’s a ripper to do? Re-rip the entire symphony with the new gear, of course!

So, for anyone who may be interested, here’s a brand new rip (now available in 24/192 too).

As always, if anyone has requests for other titles in this set, please add them to the comments or PM me directly.


What first breaks into my consciousness as I listen to the opening of the Symphony #1 is, “What fantastic first violins!” Actually, “What a fabulous first violin section!” They play as one, with enormous suppleness. The Philadelphia string section may have played more sumptuously, the Vienna Philharmonic with slightly more warmth, but you may not want either in a symphony so close to Haydn and Mozart. Keep in mind that the introduction, although beloved of musicologists, doesn’t usually constitute a high point of this symphony, but Szell’s traversal of it, with gorgeous wind solos, from the very beginning sets a standard higher than any other I’ve heard.

The first movement, lean and muscular, springs like a terrier. The second, a Haydnesque larghetto, verges on minuet, as scraps coalesce into a full melody with accompaniment. In this movement, the winds take one’s breath away. Their ensembles are perfect in their balance and fit, and extremely short solos of two notes suffice to establish these players as masters. The named Minuet is, of course, no minuet at all, but the first example of the full-blown Beethoven symphonic scherzo, an apotheosis of the hunt. We’re not in Haydnland any more. It’s got plenty of drive, although Szell doesn’t take it particularly fast. The crescendos move with inexorability, but they never, even at the climax, bluster. They succeed in part because the orchestra diminuendos seamlessly and in full dynamic control.

The trio, when it comes, features that fantastic Cleveland wind section and approaches, but never crosses into, sumptuousness. “Measure” is the key here, although it doesn’t preclude excitement. One can say the same for the finale, one of Beethoven’s wittiest. Here and there, Szell manages to bring out similarities between it and those of the Mozart #39 and #41. It begins tentatively with an idea that suddenly gathers and speeds up into the opening of the main idea, like a whip about to crack. Again, it has all the power any reasonable person wants and subtlety besides.

One really fine moment occurs at the climax of the opening allegro and the quiet transition to its repeat, all without a stumble or a sudden collapse. It’s as if you suddenly found yourself a few thousand feet lower, and yet with full support. Above all, Szell gives you a reading full of historical imagination. Beethoven probably did not hear this symphony in his head as Szell gives it to us, but it certainly conjures up the world of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. It takes a musician of immense culture to pull something like this off. — Steve Schwartz,

Track Listing:

01 – I. Adagio molto; Allegro co brio
02 – II. Andante cantabile con moto
03 – III. Menuetto: Allegro molto e vivace
04 – IV. Finale: Adagio; Allegro molto e vivace

You can see a listing of the entire Franklin Mint set here.

Ripping Info:

All vinyl is cleaned on a VPI 16.5
Milty Pro Zerostat 3

Technics SL1200-MK5 (modified)
– Rega RB300 arm with RB700 wiring
– Michell Tecnoweight
– SoundSupports armboard
– Trans-Fi Audio ResoMat
Audio Technica AT33PTG/II
AVID Pellar preamp
RME Hammerfall 9632 ADC

Processing: Sound Forge 10, ClickRepair, iZotope RX3

Do you like my rips?

If you enjoy my rips, please consider making a donation. All donations will go toward new music and/or equipment. Requests are always accepted.

Thank you!


Click here to download the files

Password is SteveMTNO.

14 thoughts on “George Szell / The Cleveland Orchestra – Beethoven: Symphony No. 1 (Franklin Mint pressing, red vinyl) – NEW RIP!”

  1. Sorry to be so late in jumping in. I listened to the previous 24/96, but I do not usually sit with 100% attention when I listen, so I missed the earlier lapse you spoke of.

    So I played the older transfer, then now to this 24/192, and there is a palpable improvement.

    Good show, Steve.
    Thanks for your much labor.

  2. Whatever, I can only get into by using previous bookmarks I’ve set other wise all I get is this

    Сайт заблокирован хостинг-провайдером.

    All my net searchers will not get me into the website.

    Any ideas or help? What’s UP?

Leave a Reply